Friday, May 29, 2009

1.The main point of Shorto's argument is that Rene Descartes is one of the key people in world history. He is valued in both religious and secular circles of knowledge. Descartes was the father of the term "cogito ergo sum" which means "I think therefore I am". This was the single phrase that echoed through out time as Descartes had just made a big point towards proving existence. Furthermore, Shorto shows how influential Descartes was by including in his article that his bones had been dug up and that many different organizations were fighting over them. Shorto also includes that the skull of Descartes was very small, and he included a story on how the size of Descartes' skull was used to prove that the size of ones cranium is not proportional to ones intelligence.

2.The thought process of the phrase "cogito ergo sum" has a very logical order. The fact that he has the capability to think means that he has a means of thinking. Since he has already established that there is no place in the human body for one to "think" he must have a mind that exists that allows him to think. And since he believes in the existence of one through the mind, then his mind exists and he exists.

3.Cartesian Dualism is the relation of mind and body. It explains that the mind uses the body to interact with the outside world. The mind is something that has no real substance. It can not be seen, only experienced. The main point of Cartesian Dualism is that there is no substance of the mind, that it exists as an intangible thing. The problem with Cartesian Dualism is that there is no true explanation for how something that does not exist in the material world can control the material world. To me, this constitutes some sort of supreme being that does things beyond our comprehension.

4.The argument that Berkeley is famous for is one that states that no one can truly explain the existence of an object, they can only explain how they perceive the object. Berkeley thought that this was true because people can interpret things such as color and relative size individually. However, this runs into the problem of universals because some things are interpreted by the same people universally because they have the same qualities.

No comments:

Post a Comment